VAR Controversy - To See Red Or Not - That Is The Question

This episode examines Wolves forward Hee-Chan’s studs-up challenge on Arsenal’s Jurien Timber and explains what the Laws of the Game (IFAB Law 12) say about studs-up tackles and serious foul play.

We outline when a studs-up challenge is likely a red card — if it endangers the opponent or uses excessive force — and when it may be downgraded to a yellow for limited force, low contact, or minimal danger.

The episode also covers how VAR reviews can upgrade decisions when slow-motion shows forceful contact, a locked leg, or contact above the ankle, and applies those tests to this incident, concluding it was a very close call.

Bottom line: studs-up is not an automatic red, but studs-up plus clear danger or excessive force should be sent off — and the debate over refereeing and VAR in cases like this continues.