Maple Leafs get No. 1 pick in NHL Draft Lottery surprise | Instant Reaction

The Toronto Maple Leafs entered Tuesday night’s NHL Draft Lottery with the No. 5 pick, and the possibility of losing their first round pick altogether, and ended up with the No. 1 pick and their choice of top-rated prospects Gavin McKenna, Ivar Stenberg, and Chase Reid. The guys discuss the Leafs’ options at first overall, what the San Jose Sharks could do after jumping up to No. 2, the Vancouver Canucks dropping to No. 3, and more.

This episode was recorded live at 7:30pm ET on May 5, 2026.

For more Athletic Hockey Show content:
- Join The Athletic Hockey Show Discord Server: discord.gg/UDmeAnvFB5
- Follow The Athletic Hockey Show wherever you listen to podcasts: podfollow.com/the-athletic-hockey-show-a-show-about-the-nhl

Follow our hosts on Bluesky:
Max Bultman: bsky.app/profile/mbultman.bsky.social
Mark Lazerus: bsky.app/profile/marklazerus.bsky.social
Jesse Granger: bsky.app/profile/jessegranger.bsky.social
Sean Gentille: bsky.app/profile/seangentille.bsky.social
Sean McIndoe: bsky.app/profile/downgoesbrown.bsky.social
Hailey Salvian: bsky.app/profile/haileysalvian.bsky.social
Scott Wheeler: bsky.app/profile/scottcwheeler.bsky.social
Chris Peters: bsky.app/profile/chrismpeters.bsky.social

Follow our hosts on X:
Max Bultman: x.com/m_bultman
Mark Lazerus: x.com/MarkLazerus
Jesse Granger: x.com/JesseGranger_
Sean Gentille: x.com/seangentille
Sean McIndoe: x.com/DownGoesBrown
Frank Corrado: x.com/frankcorrado22
Hailey Salvian: x.com/hailey_salvian
Corey Pronman: x.com/coreypronman
Chris Peters: x.com/chrismpeters
Scott Wheeler: x.com/scottcwheeler

- .com/hockeyshow

Photo credit: AP Photo/Vera Nieuwenhuis